The Great Disengagement: America’s students have checked out

When we look at the data on student engagement, something startling emerges.

From 5th grade through high school, we’re witnessing what can only be described as a mass exodus of minds.

The numbers tell a devastating story:

• 75% of 5th graders are engaged in school
• By 8th grade, only 45% remain engaged
• In 10th grade, engagement drops to 33%

Think about that for a moment. 

We’re losing two-thirds of our students’ minds along the way.

The consequences of this disengagement run deeper than academic performance. Look at the data on mental health emergency room visits for school-aged children:

Throughout 2019, emergency rooms saw dramatic spikes in mental health visits for children ages 5-17, with increases of up to 70-80% compared to baseline rates.

Look more closely at when the visits happen.

The pattern is clear:

• Mental health visits surge during the school year
• They peak during high-stress academic periods
• They decrease during summer breaks
• The trend shows progressive deterioration through the year

This isn’t coincidence.

When we create educational environments that systematically disengage students, we’re not just failing to teach them – we’re actively harming their mental health. The same system that’s losing their minds is breaking their spirits.

Think about it: We take naturally curious children and put them through a system that:

• Gradually extinguishes their love of learning
• Replaces intrinsic motivation with external pressure
• Creates anxiety about performance rather than excitement about discovery
• Forces compliance over engagement
• Values standardization over individual growth

This is bad. We must be fixing this, right?

But perhaps more startling than the numbers themselves is our collective shrug in response to them. 

We’ve somehow accepted that teenagers naturally disengage from learning, as if it were an immutable law of adolescence rather than a damning indictment of our educational system.

This acceptance is particularly troubling because engagement isn’t just some fuzzy metric about how much kids like school. 

It’s the key to how the brain learns.

When students are engaged:

• Neural pathways strengthen
• Memory consolidates
• Understanding deepens
• Learning becomes permanent

The research is unambiguous. Engaged learners show:

• Dramatically better academic performance
• Significantly higher graduation rates
• Substantially better life outcomes
• Greater likelihood of pursuing higher education
• Better job prospects
• Stronger tendencies toward lifelong learning

Why is student engagement plummeting? 

The answer lies in a perfect storm of factors. 

Our educational system, designed for the industrial age, crashes headlong into the biological and psychological realities of adolescent development.

Just when teenagers’ brains are rewiring to seek:

• Autonomy
• Social connection
• Real-world relevance

We put them in an environment that offers:

• Rigid control
• Social restriction
• Abstract learning divorced from reality

Think about a typical high school day: 

• Students move from subject to subject at the sound of a bell
• They sit through lectures on topics they had no part in choosing
• They memorize facts with no context on why they’re important
• They prepare for standardized tests that have no real-world value

It’s as if we designed a system specifically to minimize engagement.

Engagement is not a dark art

The irony? 

We know how to create engagement.

The research shows students engage when they have:

• Autonomy over their learning
• Real-world projects that matter to them
• Collaborative work opportunities
• Immediate feedback
• Clear relevance to their lives

These aren’t just theoretical approaches. They’re proven strategies that dramatically improve both engagement and learning outcomes.

So why don’t we implement these changes?

Our educational system is trapped by:

• Standardized testing requirements
• Traditional grading systems
• Rigid scheduling
• Outdated facilities
• Limited imagination about what school could be
• Incentives that don’t care about engagement

In short, we’re trying to solve 21st-century problems with 19th-century solutions.

The costs of this engagement crisis are far greater than we typically acknowledge. 

We’re not just failing to teach kids effectively; we’re actively teaching them to disengage from learning at precisely the time in history when continuous learning has become essential for survival.

The necessary revolution in education

Let’s be brutally honest: while we debate minor reforms, we’re losing an entire generation’s potential. Every day, millions of students sit in classrooms, their minds wandering, their potential wasting, their futures dimming.

The cost?

• Innovation we’ll never see
• Problems that won’t get solved
• Discoveries that won’t be made
• Leaders who won’t emerge
• Dreams that will die quietly

The good news, if there is any, is that we know how to fix this. 

• The research is clear. 
• The models exist. 
• The solutions are proven.

What’s missing is urgency. 

What’s missing is outrage.

Ask yourself: If you knew a school system was systematically destroying two-thirds of students’ natural drive to learn, wouldn’t you call that criminal? If you knew we could fix it but chose not to, wouldn’t you call that negligence?

That’s exactly what’s happening. 

Right now. In your district. In your neighborhood. Perhaps in your child’s school.

We don’t need another study. 

We don’t need more evidence. 

We don’t need incremental change.

We need a revolution.

Not tomorrow. Not next year. Now.

Every day we wait, another student decides learning isn’t for them. 

Another mind closes. 

Another future dims.

The question now is whether we have the collective will to make it happen.

The data on student engagement isn’t just a problem to solve; it’s an alarm bell ringing. The choice is ours: we can either continue to pretend we don’t hear it, or we can finally answer its call and begin the revolution.

Which side of this revolution will you be on?

---

If you read this far, some related essays you’ll also like:

1. Degrees of deception: How America’s universities became debt factories
2. Bread, circuses and education
3. The School of Entrepreneuring
4. From myth to measurement: Rethinking US News & World Report College Rankings
5. The perverse incentives driving America’s government schools
6. The endless ladder
7. Students are solving the wrong problems
8. Your kids grades are bullshit
9. Ghost nonprofits and the manufacturing of virtue